I've beaten recently Silent Hill 2, 3 and 4: The Room and now I'm playing Homecoming. 2 was awesome, such a dope mind fuck mixed with horror. 3 was also amazing, maybe even better than the second one. 4 sucked big dick. I could go on and on about its flaws but I don't see a point. It's a disgrace to the series. Also like I wrote I'm playing Homecoming now and I like it. But I'll tell more after I finish it.
Oh and if you want to see what games I've finished in my life just look at my sig. Yes, I'm a hardcore player.
Edit: So I've just beaten Silent Hill: Homecoming. It's a very good game. Combat style, vibe, music, bosses, almost everything is awesome. I think it deserves 8+/10 from me.